04 septiembre 2010
Consider below,
Justice Clarence Thomas (the best one on the Supreme Court)
"[A]t the time the original Constitution was ratified, "commerce" consisted of selling, buying, and bartering, as well as transporting for these purposes...[T]he Constitution [does] not support the proposition that Congress has authority over all activities that "substantially affect" interstate commerce...If anything, the "wrong turn" was the Court's dramatic departure in the 1930's from a century and a half of precedent. [Apart] from its recent vintage and its corresponding lack of any grounding in the original understanding of the Constitution, the substantial effects test suffers from the further flaw that it appears to grant Congress a police power over the Nation." United States v. Lopez (1995) (concurring opinion)
In Lopez, the Supreme Court struck down the Gun-Free School Zones Act of 1990. The law prohibited gun possession in a school zone. Congress justified its authority to pass such a law by relying on the Commerce Clause (regulating interstate commerce).
In fact, the commerce clause has been the tool most often used by Congress to pass basically anything they want to, with almost no limits. The aggregation technique that Justice Thomas dismisses states that an activity if in the aggregate substantially affects interstate commerce, Congress can regulate it. For example, in an infamous case, Wickard v. Filburn (1942), the Supreme Court upheld a New Deal legislation that allowed the Secretary of Agriculture to set quotas on crops. In this case, a farmer was fined for growing too much wheat on his farm. He used the wheat for himself; there was no interstate activity. The Court said that even though there was no interstate activity, if enough farmers did what Filburn did (grow too much wheat), their actions could affect interstate commerce. This view basically places little, if any, limits on the powers of Congress and ignores the 10th Amendment.
Justice Thomas put it well when he wrote: [Until] this Court replaces its existing Commerce Clause jurisprudence with a standard more consistent with the original understanding, we will continue to see Congress appropriating state police powers under the guise of regulating commerce." United States v. Morrison (2000) (concurring opinion)
This may sound all dull and boring, but the implications are extremely important. One interpretation realizes there are limits on Congressional authority to pass legislation and that some areas are not delegated to the federal government, but are reserved to the States. The other interpretation essentially says "forget the original intent, forget any boundaries" and consolidates federal control, and leaves almost no area safe from Congress.
24 marzo 2010
The Supremacy Clause in the Constitution is not a Carte Blanche for Government Expansion and Usurpation
Despite being probably the most ignored amendment by Congress, the Executive Branch, and the courts, the Tenth Amendment is still good law and is extremely relevant. The Tenth Amendment dictates that “[t]he powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.” Article Six and the Tenth Amendment are in conformity with each other. Coupled together, they place a barrier over which Congress may not cross. Congress may not pass legislation in areas not delegated to it by the Constitution. Congress, has of course, often ignored this constitutional barrier. While Congress has ignored the barrier, the States are not required, and should not, do the same.
Congressional disregard for the powers reserved to the States does not force the States nor give them an excuse to show the same callous disregard for the constitutional barriers. The assumption that whatever Congress does is constitutional and unquestionable should be dismissed. Questions should not give way to anarchy or disregard for the law. Proper regard for the law, however, requires that the States as well as Congress and the courts carefully consider these constitutional questions. The federal government has unquestionably grown to mammoth proportions and shows no signs of slowing down. With the passage of recent bills, nothing seems out of reach of the notions of Congress. Again, federal usurpation and disregard for federalism and the checks and balances system gives no excuse for others to do the same. If States allow themselves to be trodden under foot by the actions of Congress, they must share some of the blame.
The current situation brings other notable events to mind. One is the tax on tea and stamps. Another is the Tariff of Abominations of 1832. It is no stretch in stating that the government takeover of health care is a more blatant use of power than these two prior events. If Congress is allowed to pass this with silent acquiescence on the part of the States, what is to be restrained from further federal usurpation of power? The States must counter this whether it be in the form of filing a lawsuit or even refusing to implement the act which has no basis in constitutional authority.
08 noviembre 2009
A Spanish Song of Praise
Defendamos de nuestros enemigos.
Eres muy alto en los cielos
Alleluia
Salvanos por favor de esta tempestad.
Gloria a Dios, todo poderoso,
Y lleno de misericordia.
Gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria,
Gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria,
Gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria, gloria!
Alleluia, allulia, alluia!
A Latin Blessing
Non pax ad malum
Veritas numquam perrit.
Hilarem datorem diligit Deus.
Veni, vidi, vici!
Semper fidelis.
Sanctus, sanctus, sanctus.
28 julio 2009
Election
A paraphrase from one of Eld. David Pyles's sermons is that if God knew who the "choosers" and "losers" would be when brought into existence, He knew who the "choosers" and "losers" would be if brought into existence. Unconditional election is the unavoidable conclusion. Everybody by nature is a "loser," but God elected (chose) a people for His own.
08 mayo 2009
A List of Good Books to Read Recently Read by the Author of this List (not all necessarily in order) and some accompanying comments
1. Polk by Walter R. Borneman –a very informative and enjoyable read on President James K. Polk of Tennessee. Whether or not one agrees with Polk politically, he was remarkably successful in accomplishing his agenda. Another good point about the book is that while learning about Polk, one learns much about the history of the era and other important characters.
2. James Madison and the Struggle for the Bill of Rights by Richard Labunski –a fascinating description of what took place to add the Bill of Rights to the Constitution. Those who are Anti-Federalists can appreciate that the Bill of Rights was added by their insistence although some like Patrick Henry, a giant of orators, wanted more provisions.
3. The Dirty Dozen: How Twelve Supreme Court Cases Radically Expanded Government and Eroded Freedom by Robert A. Levy and William Mellor –even for those not particularly interested in constitutional law, this book isn’t a waste of time. You may not agree with all the author’s assertions, but they make many good points and show how the Supreme Courts has often erred in its rulings.
4. Centennial Crisis: The Disputed Election of 1876 by William Rehnquist –for those who gained political passion in Bush v. Gore in 2000, this book serves as somewhat of a prequel, over a century before. The late Supreme Court Chief Justice Rehnquist writes in vivid detail of the disputed election of Rutherford B. Hayes over Samuel J. Tilden and the behind the scenes work that went into the event.
5. Washington’s Secret War: The Hidden History of Valley Forge by Thomas Fleming –this book fills in a gap of a lesser known aspect about Washington—he was a good politician and knew how to fight off his opponents who were jealous and tried to undermine him.
6. Hamilton’s Curse: How Jefferson’s Arch Enemy Betrayed the American Revolution—and What it Means for Americans Today by Thomas J. Dilorenzo –beware of reading this if you are a dyed-in-the-wool Federalist, although Alexander Hamilton went further in his views than a lot of other Federalists. This book explains how Hamilton influenced our economy (for the worse) through government debt, a national bank, and many other things.
7. Lincoln Unmasked: What You’re Not Supposed to Know About Dishonest Abe by Thomas J. Dilorenzo –this book is not for the faint of heart, especially for those who have grown up revering Lincoln. Dilorenzo presents a stunning expose of Lincoln, but instead of a book replete with personal attacks, he examines Lincoln’s actions and views. He also writes of the danger encountered by those who dare question Lincoln or his policies.
8. Economics in One Lesson by Henry Hazlitt –a good, solid book on economics. Summed up, the book discusses the fallacy of only looking at short term effects instead of the long run and looking at the effects on a group of people instead of society as a whole.
9. Civil Rights: Rhetoric or Reality? by Thomas Sowell –a very interesting book that discusses many myths and inaccuracies about the policies and ideas regarding civil rights.
10. The Vision of the Anointed by Thomas Sowell –an excellent book that talks about the elite, big government advocates who think they have the ultimate knowledge on how society should be run. Sowell is an intense researcher and his book is well documented. He states that part of the reason why the “anointed” are against families in general is that the elites dislike the family as an autonomous decision making unit that is not subject to the elite’s decisions.
11. Liberty and Tyranny: A Conservative Manifesto by Mark R. Levin –a good book describing the Conservative verses the Statist (massive, intrusive government). Topics include healthcare, Social Security, global warming (and cooling), immigration, and federalism.
12 abril 2009
My South: A Brief Description of Views and Experiences
Note: This piece stems from a short writing assignment I had from a class on Southern history. I decided to focus on the good points of this fair land (since some teachers I've had delight it seems, to focus only on negative aspects. To those not from the South, please accept my apologies. This is more pro-South than anti-anywhere else and reflects some experience I've and others have had.
The South has always invoked a strong response from me. From early childhood, I grew up thankful to live in the South. A large part of that has to do with a love for history and family heritage. Most of my relatives and friends live in the South and most of my travels have been in the same region. In fact, whenever I traveled to the North (which was not often, usually for a church meeting in Cincinnati or a town in Indiana outside of Chicago), I felt a sense of strange excitement whenever we crossed “the border.” I felt duty bound to represent my culture and location well and not be unduly influenced by the people that General Lee referred to as “those people.”
Like most young, energetic boys with any degree of imagination, I grew up playing with stick weapons and had my fair share of reenacting Confederates and Yankees. Of course, everybody who played was a Confederate and we had to fight imaginary Yankees since nobody wanted to be one. One of the best times was at my cousins’ house in the country when we had pellet guns. We had our flags waving and charged across the field. The first Gettysburg might have ended badly for us, but we were determined to be victorious this time. We were proud of the independent, freedom loving, warrior class heroes who defended their homes from invaders up North. When somebody brought up the question of slavery, we responded that of course we were against it, but like Lee and Jackson who freed their slaves, we were fighting for our state and against an oppressive government.
The South has always stood apart from the rest of the country, due in large part to shared experiences. The image of the Lost Cause may have lost its luster to the masses, but is still remembered by some. The reason why it is still important to me is because of similarities I see of what happened in the past and what is happening now. The federal government grew in leaps and bounds as a result of the War Between the States (and the New Deal) and is still growing today. Many view the states as mere subsidiaries of one huge national government. Federalism, the role of state government versus the central government, is largely ignored or forgotten. Both parties (especially the national parties) spend money like there is no tomorrow. Barriers to expansive government, and the checks and balances system, seem to have been broken or thwarted. Like the South before, I like to have government closer to the people instead of leaving it all up to ones who live in Washington D.C. most of the time.
Another important part about the South is time and place. One of the first things you ask somebody when being introduced is “Where are you from?” maybe even down to the county. If you continue for a few minutes, you have probably figured out that y’all have mutual friends or perhaps are even distant cousins. Elderly people are respected as they pass down advice, wisdom, and folklore from generation to generation. Through the ever changing times, there is a sense of stability and belonging. Religion is important as people travel long distances for two, three, or even four day church meetings when crowds gather to hear a visiting preacher. People open up their homes in genuine hospitality and everyone enjoys preaching, fellowship, and good food. In fact, friendships are often started and maintained through these meetings, and to the blessed ones, even future marriages. Singing schools, where people learn the old shape note style because they sing a cappella in their churches, are held usually in the summer.
Not even a cursory discussion of the South is complete without mentioning the stunningly delicious cuisine. Creamed corn, mashed potatoes, black-eyed peas, gravy, biscuits, fried chicken, collard greens, and the ubiquitous barbecue (though Memphis has the best), are all admired and enjoyed. More could be written, but these are all things that comprise my South.
13 febrero 2009
Passionate Ramblings on Government, Life, and Freedom
Forgive the length of this post. Don't feel obligated to read the whole thing.
These are just a few (somewhat disjointed thoughts) I've had recently while
thinking about our country. Sometimes it gets discouraging, but God is in
control. Isaiah 45:18.
Politically (as well as morally in many ways) our country is in bad shape. I just read of some bill passed by both houses about a so called Gender Based Fair Pay Act that makes it easier for people to sue if they think they are being discriminated against. First, where does Congress derive the authority to pass such legislation? Interstate Commerce? Secondly, how is this a national matter? Thirdly, what about people's right to discriminate? How should that be less than a right to "privacy?" Working a job is voluntary. What basis does anyone have to sue because of perceived pay discrimination? The freedom to make choices is a wonderful liberty we have. Where to work, what kind of job, or even to quit a job if we need to. (For the record, people need to know the whole definition of discriminate. People discriminate restaurants based on food, prices, service etc.) Fourthly, with further regulations on hiring practices, including pay, the govt. isn't helping people. In fact, it could lead to future layoffs or prevent hiring in the first place. Do I think there are some bad people that run businesses? Undoubtedly they exist. Do I run to Uncle Sam to fix everything? No! The action of running to Uncle Sam to fix everything (especially in the first resort) is one of the great detriments of our society.
Even when problems exist, the govt. (especially Congress) is not always (and mostly not) the best route to take for a solution. Recently, in a History of the New South class, we watched a clip from the movie Gettysburgh about Pickett's Charge. I don't always like to think about the late war, because of painful recollections. I was stirred up again, however, and wondered what I could take from that. For 15,000 men to charge a long field of open ground against men in entrenched positions and heavy cannon fire meant something. What are some of the connections then and today politically? For a sample, the role and nature of government. We, and most Southernors, relative to the rest of the population are patriotic. We care about our country and we mourn when it goes down and strays from good principles. We are wary, now as well as then, of central power in the hands of those who are in DC most of the time. We fear encroachments on liberty, burdensome regulations, high taxes (I might add, much more heavy than the tea tax that led to the Boston Tea Party) and much more. Further, we loath too much consolidation of power, and too many national laws. If Maine wants to make laws about a Maineish issue, let them, but do not always extend the same to Tennessee. Federalism, separation of power, balance of power, checks and balances etc. we like but find they are being lost.
Why should Congress be the grand depository of our hopes and trust of solutions? Why should we always cry for more government services when the very process lessens our liberty and makes us dependants of the state (need I say wards like in Bleak House?) Why do I refuse to take the position of being "against kids" when I'm opposed to expanding Pre-K programs? I'm very pro-kid. Do I think it in their best interest to be instructed by govt. teachers at the wee ages of 3, 4, and 5? Are there some parents not doing their job? Assuredly, they can be found. Is that enough of an excuse to give govt. the appellation of "Babysitter?" A thousand times nay! (I won't go into voluntary and involuntary pre-K right now, just the general issue.) Cradle to grave is not far from the situation right now. The teachers well meaning though they be, can't teach certain thinks to young tykes. Can they teach true morality with leaving out the Bible? Are we encouraging parents to transfer their God-given authority and responsibility to the government? We have to make choices. I side on the parents, not the govt. People can always point to exceptions (I heard them in Nashville aplenty), but the govt. doesn't necessarily have a glowing track record.
Finally, a rule of economics is nothing is free. How is the "free" handout given you? Somebody had to pay for it. If any of y'all have read this far, congratulations. Sometimes, these thoughts lie dormant, and at times, they rise to the surface like the "streams of the south." (See Daddy's sermon on that.)
Really finally, things are connected. We could give up politically, but should we? These have spiritual implications as well. Should we give up as Christians because times are tough? Assuredly not. We can pray and do what we can. We can't be responsible for everybody else, but we are accountable to God for our actions.
Reflections and Exhortations, An Essay
Setiago
24 noviembre 2008
The Mighty Missipp'
Whose waves wash up our banks,
Marks the edge of our city.
The riverboats, barges, and small craft
Wind up and down the river.
A peaceful scene this is-
The blue sky, shining sun, green grass,
Cotton-like clouds and people walking
To and fro, combine for a somewhat
Tranquil yet energetic setting.
02 octubre 2008
A Bit of Beowulf
H.R. Ellis Davidson, The Sword in Anglo-Saxon England: Its Archaeology and Literature, (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1962), 195,196
03 diciembre 2007
History
History is a fascinating topic, both recent and ancient. The other day, whilst waiting for a class, I decided to walk around campus and go into some buildings which I had never before entered. I walked up to the administration building with some trepidation, but decided to march boldly inside. What an intriguing place with many stories of its own. The same I thought for other buildings, especially a particular room in Brister, the old library.
Now, I had wanted to go inside this mysterious room before, but it is open only on certain select hours. Aha-now open on Fridays-1:30-4. I can, I must, I shall go thought I to myself and glad I was for going. The room is full of school memorabilia and an excellent place to browse. So, a bunch of old junk. Nay, rather a collection of treasure! Maybe that's one reason I chose to become a history major.
22 octubre 2007
Pride and Humility: Submission Before the Mighty God
Thus said a once arrogant king who was shamefully humbled. After lifting himself up and declaring what great things he had done, "he was driven from men, and did eat grass as oxen, and his body was wet with the dew of heaven, till his hairs were grown like eagles' feathers, and his nails like birds' claws." -Daniel 4:33
It is easy, though foolish, to get lifted up in pride. When we let our minds wander and let ourselves get puffed up with thinking of our great accomplishments and how wonderful we are, we are traversing a dangerous path. We would do well to remember how small we are and how big God is. God is able to raise up kings and to cast them down. Nebuchadnezzar learned his lesson after being humbled by God and gave Him due praise and honor. We can do no less. Daniel 4:37 "...those who walk in pride he is able to abase."
08 mayo 2007
A Resurgence
Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution lists the duties of Congress including the right "to exercise exclusive legislation in all cases whatsoever over such district (not exceeding ten miles square) as may, by cession of particular States and the acceptance of Congress, become the seat of the government of the United States,..."
This section makes it clear the Washington, D.C. is supposed to be under the direct control of Congress. Now, let us look at Article 1, Section 1 which describes what composes Congress.
Art. 1, Section 1 "The House of Representatives shall be composed of members chosen every second year by the people of the several States,.."
Likewise, in Section 3 "The Senate of the United States shall be composed of two Senators from each State,..."
Article 1 clearly states that only States (not districts, territories, D.C. Puerto Rico, Guam, other islands etc.) can send members to Congress. Why then, has the House of Representatives just passed this blatantly unconstitutional bill? Is it because some want another liberal vote in Congress? Is it because out of compassion for the non-represented people in D.C.? Is it because of misunderstanding, ignorance, or conniving?
I am convinced more and more that although some are ignorant of the Constitution, many others totally disregard it and pass all sorts of legislation if it suits their wishes.
19 marzo 2007
Three Cheers for Tennessee!
Joey Dorsey's blocks are incredible, his dunks are amazing, and his rebounds are authoritative. The Tigers did a fantastic job of rallying and finishing off Nevada after CDR injured his ankle. Great times, Tiger fans!
09 marzo 2007
09 enero 2007
A Winter Afternoon
The first month of the year, the seventh day.
The long looked for event has now come nigh,
The cooler weather, the ominous sky
Bodes a wintry mix, though slight it would seem.
The clouds block even the smallest sun beam.
The cool, gentle breeze was swirling around
While falling to the earth was something white.
‘Twas a tranquil scene with almost no sound
With the small snowflakes—a wonderful sight.
True, once on the ground, the flakes were all gone,
They were hard to see even in the sky.
But in that moment, those who were alone
Saw the tiny snowflakes and looked on high.
Silent they stood, a joyful time serene
‘Twas not on the ground, a carpet pristine,
But they could see it swirling in the breeze
Here and now there among the leafless trees.
E’en though it was not much, this did they know-
They could be thankful and dream of more snow.
19 diciembre 2006
11 noviembre 2006
Thoughts on Various Things: Weather, Politics, and Sports
Having said that, I hope that those in Congress will remember that defeating bad measures is as important as passing good measures. Now may be a time to be on the defensive with certain politicians having gained prominent places of power, but let not the fear of being called a "Do Nothing Congress" stop those who would defeat the passage of harmful bills even if that may not seem as glamorous as getting ones name attached to a certain harmful measure. Remeber the Latin phrase, sadly often forgotten during the last six years, "Veto" or "I forbid."
Lastly, having been to many football games this year, remember the famous phrase, "There stands Jackson like a stone wall." Remember that, defensive line!
25 octubre 2006
Do, Mi, Sol, La, So, La
So here's to the Mozarts, Bachs, and Handels through whose music we enjoy beautiful arrangements of sound and unforgettable strains of delightful melody that stimulate our sense of order and rightness.